After a chance encounter at a pastor’s breakfast, Pastor Bob and Pastor Tom had been meeting together for several years. Although they were from different denominations, they both felt the call of God to reach the community with the message of salvation through Jesus Christ. Putting aside denominational differences, they met together, prayed together as brothers in the Lord and developed a deep friendship.
Both churches they served had reached a plateau of 150. As they talked one morning, Bob realized that a family had left his church and gone to Tom’s. Likewise, Tom realized that a family had left his church and gone to Bob’s. This wasn’t the first time they had “swapped sheep.”
Neither could remember the last time they had a person profess faith in Jesus Christ for the first time. Feeling discouraged, they realized they needed to do something to have a greater impact. They found a survey tool and agreed to use it in their respective churches. What follows is their story…
A tale of two churches…
Monday morning
“Morning Bob.”
“Good morning Tom. Sorry I’m a few minutes late. I see Judy already has coffee ready.”
“No problem on the time. I was just enjoying my first cup. What did you bring this morning?”
“I received it in the mail yesterday. It is a sample packet for a survey tool I think we can use. A friend of mine who pastors a church on the coast suggested I take a look at it.”
“A survey? What kind of survey?”
“It’s called the Spiritual Growth and Community Impact Survey. It is a survey for the entire church to take during worship. There are only 36 questions – most of which are ‘yes’ and ‘no’ answers.”
The two pastors sat together, drinking coffee and enjoying breakfast. As they reviewed the survey, they tried to discern how their leadership teams and the congregation would respond. With some trepidation but clear resolution, both agreed to take it back to their leadership teams. Regardless of the reception, they both wanted to make the attempt to help their churches grow spiritually deeper and reach out more to the community.
Tuesday evening – Pastor’s Bob’s church
Mike practically leapt out of his chair. His fist pounded hard on the table.
“This is church!” he exclaimed. “You want to give people a test in the middle of a church service?”
“No, no” answered Pastor Bob, trying to remain calm. “This is not a test. It’s a survey. I simply want to help us get some more information so we can move forward.”
“We are moving forward,” yelled Mike. “We approved fixing up the children’s wing. We are launching a capital campaign to build a new fellowship hall. Choir is starting up again. We are supporting a new missionary family. There is a lot happening.”
“I know. And I don’t want to stop any of that activity right now. I simply think it would benefit the church if we could prayerfully take a look inside at the health of our church and how we are reaching out.”
Fred, ever the diplomat, motioned for attention. “Mike, I hear you and I certainly agree that we are very busy right now. But, if I’m hearing Pastor correctly, this wouldn’t take away from any of that. In fact, it might help us as we look towards plans for the new building and how it will be used. I think we should try this.”
“Well, I don’t. I vote no,” replied Mike angrily.
Pastor Bob lowered his head sadly. As the voices around him argued back and forth, he chastised himself for even bringing this up. He didn’t need any more of his leaders angry with him. Fred, noticing the slump of the pastor’s shoulders, called for attention.
“Friends, I don’t know if this will be a good thing for the church or not. Pastor obviously feels that it will help all of us and I feel inclined to support him. Let’s go ahead and put it to a vote,” said Fred. “All those in favor?”
The vote was 5 to 4. Although it wasn’t the ringing endorsement he had hoped for, Pastor Bob was nevertheless happy it was going forward.
Wednesday evening – Pastor Tom’s church
“Do you really think we need to do this Pastor?” asked Judy. “I mean, I’m not against it, but what will we do with the information? What if we aren’t doing well? I don’t know what we would do if we had more families leave because we changed things.”
“I understand your apprehension, Judy,” Tom replied. “But the survey is only going to provide us with information. It is up to us to determine what we are going to do with it.”
“Have you looked at some of these questions, though?” asked Bill. “As I understand it, we are supposed to make guesses about how people will respond.”
“Not quite, Bill,” said Tom. “We don’t guess how people will respond. We need to set some expectations for what we would like to see at our church.”
“OK – but I want to see 100% of these things. The first “yes or no” statement is: I am sure of my salvation through Jesus Christ. I want to have 100% of the people in our church knowing Jesus Christ as their personal Savior. Does anyone not want that?”
“I don’t,” said Joe.
Everyone turned to Joe in surprise.
“What do you mean Joe?” asked Rachel. “You can’t be serious!”
“I am. Everyone who joins our church must be sure of their salvation through Christ. And I do want people to give their lives to Christ. But I don’t want to have everyone visiting our church to already have that relationship. Would we really be doing outreach and evangelism if that were true? I want to see people visiting our church who are seeking that relationship. I want to see people every week who want to know more about Jesus. Maybe I’m wrong, but I think that is what a church that is really looking outwardly to fulfill the Great Commission would have on Sunday morning.”
The room grew quiet. Joe’s words had opened their eyes to something they hadn’t considered in a long time. Had they grown complacent to reaching out with the love of Christ?
“Pastor Tom? Could we have a time of prayer? After that, I’d like to vote,” said Judy.
The vote was unanimous. Every leader wanted to do the survey.